About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



21 Stetson L. Rev. 163 (1991-1992)
The Proper Interpretation of Corporate Constituency Statutes and Formulation of Director Duties

handle is hein.journals/stet21 and id is 173 raw text is: THE PROPER INTERPRETATION OF
CORPORATE CONSTITUENCY STATUTES AND
FORMULATION OF DIRECTOR DUTIES*
Steven M.H. Wallman**
At least twenty-eight states have adopted some form of the so-
called nonshareholder constituency or stakeholder statutes.1
Such labels belie, however, the more important and subtle notion ar-
ticulated by these statutes: what this article calls the corporate con-
stituency concept. This article first describes these statutes - more
accurately referred to as corporate constituency statutes - and de-
fines the proper standard to govern directors' actions - the best
interests of the corporation standard. Next this article reviews the
competing standards for director duties and shows why the formula-
tion of this standard embodied in the corporate constituency concept
is the superior standard for director decisionmaking both in connec-
tion with ordinary business matters and takeovers. The article also
outlines the benefits of the corporate constituency paradigm and its
promise as a model for defining the duties of directors of major pub-
lic corporations. Finally, this article rebuts objections raised by oppo-
nents of the corporate constituency statutes.
THE CORPORATE CONSTITUENCY STATUTES
In many venues, the debate over the merits of the corporate con-
stituency statutes has been clouded by misunderstanding as to what
the statutes say. Thus, the actual language of the statutes presents a
useful starting point.2 In 1983 Pennsylvania adopted the first of these
statutes:
* Copyright © 1991 by Steven M.H. Wallman.
** J.D. 1978, Columbia University School of Law; M.S. 1976 Sloan School of Management,
Massachusetts Institute of Technology; B.S. 1975 Massachusetts Institute of Technology. The
author is a partner in the Washington, D.C., office of Covington & Burling. He is the co-drafter
of the first corporate constituency statute enacted in 1983 and the drafter of the recent Penn-
sylvania corporate law amendments reaffirming the corporate constituency concept. He grate-
fully acknowledges the helpful comments of Kathleen Wallman, Ellen Ranard, and Michael
Cutler.
1. See appendix A to this article for an analysis of the current corporate constituency
statutes.
2. See Symposium appendix, infra p. 279, for the pertinent language of all current
statutes.