About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



16 Indian J. L. & Tech. 18 (2020)
The Interaction between Competition Law & Digital and E-Commerce Markets in India

handle is hein.journals/indiajoula16 and id is 192 raw text is: THE INTERACTION BETWEEN

COMPETITION LAW & DIGITAL AND
E-COMMERCE MARKETS IN INDIA
Anshuman Sakle and Nandini Pahari*

I. Introduction: Developments in the
Digital and E-commerce Domains
in  India  ......................  18
II. Regulatory Framework for
Dealing with Competition Law
Concerns in the E-Commerce
Sector  .......................  20
A. Section 3(4) of the Act
(Vertical restraints) ......... 20
B. Section 4 (Abuse of
dominance) ............... 22
III. Delineation of the E-Commerce
Sector as a Separate 'Relevant
M arket ' ....................... 23
IV. The Competition Law issues dealt
by the CCI in the E-Commerce
Sector  . ..  ...... ........... . 25
A. Minimum RPM. .. .. .. .. . .. 25

B. Other novel competition law
concerns  ................. 26
i. Concerns under Section 3(4)
of the  Act. ................  26
ii. Concerns under Section 4 of
the  Act. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ...  27
V. Objective Justifications and Pro-
Competitive Benefits ............ 30
VI.  E-commerce Report. ............  31
A. Background of the
E-commerce Report ........ 31
B. Issues discussed in the
E-commerce Report ........ 32
C. Implications of the
E-commerce study.......... 33
VII. International Jurisprudence on
Sim ilar Issues................. . 35
VIII. Concluding Remarks............ 36

I. INTRODUCTION: DEVELOPMENTS IN THE DIGITAL AND
E-COMMERCE DOMAINS IN INDIA
The recent tiff between Amazon and Walmart-owned Flipkart on one hand
and the Competition Commission of India (CCI) on the other, has been
making headlines for the last couple of months. While the CCI directed the
Director General (DG) to conduct a probe against the exclusive practices of
these two popular e-retailers under Section z6(z) of the Competition Act,
zooz (as amended) (Act),1 the Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka (Karnataka
High Court) stayed the investigations.2 First Amazon and then Flipkart
Anshuman Sakle is a Partner with the Competition Practice at Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas.
Nandini Pahari is an Associate with the Competition Practice at Cyril Amarchand
Mangaldas.
1 S 26(1) Order in Delhi Vyapar Mahasangh v Flipkart Internet (P) Ltd 2020 SCC OnLine
CCI 3.
2 Stay order of the Karnataka High Court, available at <https://tech.economictimes.indi-
atimes.com/news/internet/karnataka-high-court-grants-stay-on-ccis-probe-for-eight-
weeks/74136975> accessed 12 May 2020.