About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



48 Harv. Int'l L.J. 105 (2007)
A System of Selective Substitute Compliance

handle is hein.journals/hilj48 and id is 111 raw text is: VOLUME 48, NUMBER 1, WINTER 2007

A System of Selective Substitute Compliance
Howell E. Jackson*
In the field of securities regulation, there is something of a tradition for sen-
ior SEC officials to float major new initiatives in the pages of law reviews.
The classic example is Milton Cohen's Truth in Securities Revisited, which
appeared in the Harvard Law Review in 1966 and laid the conceptual ground-
work for the integration of disclosure standards under federal securities laws
and eventually the now-familiar practice of incorporation by reference.' Ethio-
pis Tafara and Robert Peterson's Blueprint for Cross-Border Access to U.S. Inves-
tors may someday be seen as having a similar impact on the application of fed-
eral securities law to foreign entities.2
The idea underlying their new framework is what they call a system of
substituted compliance, which I amend in the title of this comment by
inserting the crucial concept of selectivity.3 Despite its bland formulation, their
proposal would constitute a major change in U.S. policy. Historically, the SEC
has taken the position that when foreign entities intentionally enter U.S.
markets (and sometimes even when the entrance is unintentional), federal secu-
rities laws apply in the same manner as our rules apply to U.S. domestic enti-
ties.4 While some small accommodations for some foreign entities have long
been permitted--especially in the case of foreign private issuers-the over-
* James S. Reid, Jr., Professor of Law, Harvard Law School. Several of the themes explored in this
comment are based on issues covered over the past six years in the International Finance Seminar that
Professor Hal Scott and I have been teaching at Harvard Law School. Also helpful were discussions with
European and American academics and regulators at a Roundtable Discussion on the EU-US Transatlan-
tic Dialogue on Financial Services Regulation held at Cambridge University under the auspices of the
Centre for Corporate and Commercial Law in September 2005.
1. Milton H. Cohen, Truth in Securities Revisited, 79 HARV. L. REV. 1340 (1966). Prior to writing
this piece, Cohen was the Director of the SEC's Special Study on Securities Markets.
2. Ethiopis Tafara & Robert J. Peterson, A Blueprint for Cross-Border Access to U.S. Investors: A New In-
ternational Framework, 48 HARV. INT'L L.J. 31 (2007).
3. Selectively incorporating foreign regulatory structures into the law of developing countries is an
idea I explored a number of years ago in Howell E. Jackson, Selective Incorporation of Foreign Legal Systems to
Promote Nepal as an International Financial Services Center, in REGULATION AND DEREGULATION: POLICY
AND PRACTICE IN THE UTILITIES AND FINANCIAL SERVICES INDUSTRIES 367 (Christopher McCrudden
ed., 1999).
4. This policy-a form of national treatment-has an intuitive appeal. As SEC Commissioner Roel
Campos once justified the U.S. position: foreign exchanges are more than welcome in our markets-
under the same terms that apply to U.S. exchanges. Roel C. Campos, Convergence and Beyond, Speech
to the U.S.-Europe Symposium, Program on International Financial Systems (Nov. 15, 2003), available
at htrp://www.sec.gov/news/speech/spchl11503rcc.htm. But the SEC has, over the years, recognized a
number of exceptions to this policy. See infra note 20 (reviewing accommodations for foreign private
issuers).
5. See infra notes 17-18 (discussing current SEC accommodations for foreign firms).