About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



82 U. Colo. L. Rev. 431 (2011)
Urbanization, Water Quality, and the Regulated Landscape

handle is hein.journals/ucollr82 and id is 435 raw text is: URBANIZATION, WATER QUALITY, AND
THE REGULATED LANDSCAPE
DAVE OWEN*
Watershed scientists frequently describe urbanization as a
primary cause of water quality degradation, and recent stud-
ies conclude that even in lightly-developed watersheds, ur-
banization often precludes attainment of water quality stan-
dards.    This Article considers legal responses to this
pervasive problem. It explains why traditional legal mea-
sures have been ineffective, and it evaluates several recent
innovations piloted in the northeastern United States. These
innovations are potentially applicable across the nation.
Specifically, the innovations involve using impervious cover
total maximum daily loads, residual designation authority,
and collective permitting to expand, intensify, and modify
regulatory control of urban stormwater. More generally, the
innovations involve transferring regulatory focus from end-
of-the-pipe to landscape-based controls.    The Article con-
cludes that these innovations, while raising some new prob-
lems, represent a promising shift. It then discusses addi-
tional reforms and research needed to better reconcile legal
water quality standards and traditional land development
patterns. It also evaluates the federalism implications of
this shift, and closes by considering some of the difficult pri-
oritization questions raised by urban watershed restoration
efforts.
INTRODUCTION                            ........................................432
I. URBANIZATION, DEGRADATION, AND THE LIMITS OF
TRADITIONAL REGULATION                      ................ .........439
A. Urban Stream Syndrome.............                ......439
B. Traditional Legal Responses ..................445
* Associate Professor, University of Maine School of Law. I thank Tony Arnold,
Colin Apse, Eric Biber, Curtis Bohlen, Karen Cappiella, Dan Esty, David Hart,
Rita Heimes, Steve Hinchman, Bjorn Lake, Sarah Schindler, Jenny Wriggins, and
participants at the Stanford-Yale Junior Faculty Workshop for comments on ear-
lier drafts, and Peter Glaser, Meghan Ogren, Reeve Wood, Randa Capponi, and
Shannon Carroll for excellent research assistance. Research for this article was
supported by National Science Foundation award EPS-0904155 to Maine EPSCoR
at the University of Maine and by the University of Maine School of Law. I also
thank the staff members of the University of Colorado Law Review for their excel-
lent work.