About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



12 J.L. & Pol'y 327 (2003-2004)
Insider Trading: Why to Commit the Crime from a Legal and Psychological Pespective

handle is hein.journals/jlawp12 and id is 337 raw text is: INSIDER TRADING: WHY TO COMMIT THE
CRIME FROM A LEGAL AND
PSYCHOLOGICAL PESPECTIVE
Emily A. Malone*
INTRODUCTION
Insider trading,' a crime that often involves the wealthy getting
wealthier, is a behavior associated with cheating and greed.2 It is
also a crime that is apparently difficult to deter.3 This phenomenon
can be illustrated by exploring current events. Insider trading hit
the newsstands again last year with the scandal involving the
ImClone Systems Inc. corporation (ImClone) and celebrity
businesswoman Martha Stewart.4 This note uses that example as an
* Brooklyn Law School, Class of 2004.
Although not defined in any statute or regulation, for the purpose of this
note insider trading is the use of material, nonpublic information in trading the
shares of a company .... BLACK'S LAW DICTIONARY 798 (7th ed. 1999). For
the purpose of this note, only the distinct crime of inside trading will be
analyzed. Other forms of white collar crime will not be addressed.
2 See discussion infra Part II.B.1.b (discussing the connection between
insider trading and behavior associated with cheating and greed).
3 See discussion infra Part II (discussing why the normative and legal costs
associated with insider trading fail to effectively deter the crime).
4 See JAMES WILLIAM COLEMAN, THE CRIMINAL ELITE 89 (2d ed. 1989)
(listing prominent businessmen as defendants in the 1987 insider trading
scandal: a partner in Goldman Sachs; the Director of Kidder, Peabody; the head
of risk arbitrage for Merrill Lynch; Vice Presidents from Paine Webber, E. F.
Hutton, Kidder, Peabody, and Shearson Lehman Brothers...); see also
Holman W. Jenkins Jr., Business World. An Autumnal Resolution: Give Martha
a Break, WALL ST. J., Sept. 4, 2002, at A23 (putting the coverage of Martha
Stewart on par with impending war with Iraq). This scandal will be used in a
hypothetical context as an illustration of the theories explored by this note. See