About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



8 J. Int'l Bus. & L. 169 (2009)
Belhas v. Ya'Alon: The Case for a Jus Cogens Exception to the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act

handle is hein.journals/jibla8 and id is 171 raw text is: 






                       BELHAS V. YA'ALON:

   THE CASE FOR A JUS COGENS EXCEPTION TO THE

          FOREIGN SOVEREIGN IMMUNITIES ACT


                              Graham Ogilvy*


                              INTRODUCTION

         In Belhas v. Ya'alon, the Circuit Court for the District of Columbia
dismissed the complaint brought against General Moshe Ya'alon, a retired
Israeli general, on the grounds that any potential international law violations
committed by General Ya'alon occurred while he was acting in his official
capacity with the Israeli military. The alleged violations included war crime,
extrajudicial killings, crimes against humanity, and torture. Taking for granted
the details alleged in the complaint, General Ya'alon's actions constituted
serious jus cogens violations. Despite the severity of these violations, the court
held that General Ya'alon's position in the Israeli military made him immune
from suit under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act. This note will argue
that, due to the nature of jus cogens norms and the standing they hold in the
international community, the court should have found and applied a jus cogens
exception to the immunity provided by the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act.

               I. BELHAS V. YA'ALON: FACTUAL BACKGROUND

         Saadallah Belhas and other plaintiffs brought an appeal before the
District of Columbia Circuit Court after their claims were dismissed in the
district court for lack of subject matter jurisdiction because of sovereign
immunity claimed by the defendant Moshe Ya'alon, an Israeli General, under
the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA).' The plaintiffs brought their


* J.D. Candidate, 2010, Hofstra University School of Law. First of all I would like to thank Morgan
McCord, my Notes and Comments Editor, and Elizabeth Streelman, Senior Editor for Articles, for
helping to edit and prepare this note for publication. I would also like to thank the rest of the senior
staff of the Journal of International Business and Law for their support, and Professor Curtis Pew
for serving as my faculty advisor. Finally, I would like to thank my family for providing the
support and encouragement that has been so vital to my law school career.
Belhas v. Ya'alon, 515 F.3d 1279, 1282 (D.C. Cir. 2008).