About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



64 Calif. L. Rev. 74 (1976)
The Initiative and Referendum's Use in Zoning

handle is hein.journals/calr64 and id is 87 raw text is: COMMENTS
The Initiative and Referendum's
Use in Zoning
Craig N. Orent
In recent years, there has been a surge of litigation involving the
validity of the use of the initiative and referendum in zoning. The
author examines the various arguments against allowing the initiative
and referendum's use, and concludes that an adequate case has not
been made for prohibiting these devices in zoning.
American courts are divided on whether voters may use the initia-
tive' to enact, or the referendum2 to challenge, municipal zoning mea-
t A.B. 1973, University of California; third-year student, Boalt Hall School of
Law.
1. The initiative permits the direct enactment of legislation by the voters. A
proposed measure is placed on the ballot upon certification of petitions bearing the
required number of signatures (generally ranging from five to 25% of registered voters).
For examples of initiative procedures, see CAL. ELEc. CODE §§ 4000-23 (West Supp.
1975), implementing CAL. CONST. art. IV, § 25; N.J. STAT. ANN. §§ 40:69A-184 to -196
(1967); Omo R.C.A. §§ 731.28-.4 (Page 1953), implementing Orno CONST. art. II, § If.
The local legislative body often has the option of passing a proposed initiative measure
after certification rather than placing it on the ballot. See, e.g., CAL. ELEC. CODE §§
4011-12 (West Supp. 1975); N.J. STAT. ANN. § 40:69A-191 (1967). Amendment of the
initiative measure by the legislative body after passage is often restricted. See, e.g., CAL.
ELEC. CODE § 4015 (West 1968); NEV. R.S. § 295.025 (1973).
2. The referendum allows voters to force an ordinance passed by the local
legislative body to -be submitted for a vote of the people. Opponents of a proposed
ordinance typically must file a petition bearing the required number of signatures
between final passage and the ordinance's effective date (often 30 days after passage). If
the ordinance is not promptly repealed by the legislative body, its operation is suspended
and it is placed on the ballot for popular vote. See, e.g., CAL. ELEC. CODE §§ 4050-57
(West Supp. 1975). The referendum procedure supplements the initiative, which can be
used to propose the repeal of an existing ordinance.
The initiative and referendum both stem from the Progressive movement of the
1900's. Progressives believed that the initiative and referendum and similar devices
would:
deprive machine government of the advantages it had in checkmating popular
control, and make government accessible to the superior disinterestedness of
the average citizen. Then, with the power of the bosses broken or crippled,
it would be possible to check the incursions of the interests upon the welfare
of the people and realize a cleaner, more efficient government.
R. HOFsTADTER, THE AGE OF REFORM 225 (1955). Controversy has raged over whether
the initiative and referendum indeed accomplish these goals. See, e.g., W. CRoucH, T-n'
INITATiVE AND REFERENDUM IN CALIFoRN A 21-25 (1950); H. CROLY, PROoRESSIVE
DEMOCRACY 306 (1914); W. MUNRO, THE GOVERNMENT OF AMERICAN CITIS (4th ed.
1939).