About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



38 B.U. Int'l L.J. 286 (2020)
Under the Istrian Sun: Navigating International Law Solutions for the Slovenia-Croatia Maritime Border Dispute

handle is hein.journals/builj38 and id is 298 raw text is: 













           UNDER THE ISTRIAN SUN: NAVIGATING
INTERNATIONAL LAW SOLUTIONS FOR THE SLOVENIA-
            CROATIA MARITIME BORDER DISPUTE

                        CHRISTOPHER M. HARTLEY*



                                 ABSTRACT
   Twenty-eight years after Slovenia and Croatia exited the Federation of
Yugoslavia on the eve of its bloody civil war, the two countries are still plagued
by a maritime border dispute in the northern Adriatic Sea.' Given that the
countries were not in conflict with each other during the war, and given their
similar goals for integration into the greater European and international
communities, it is perplexing that they have not been able to resolve this dispute.
The Bay of Piran (or, Piran Bay), located in the narrow Gulf of Trieste at the
land border of the two countries and having a unique, heavily indented
geography, is ground zero of this dispute. 2 The pivotal issues are sovereign
control of the bay itself and access for Slovenian vessels to international waters,
a concept that is foreclosed under traditional law of the sea maritime border
principles given the constraints of the bay and Slovenia's miniscule coastline.3



  *Assistant Professor, Department of Law, United States Military Academy, West Point.
The author is an active duty Army Judge Advocate. The author was a United States military
liaison to the Republic of Slovenia's Ministry of Defense from October 1995 through July
1996. Numerous visits to the Slovenian and Istrian region since his residence there help
broaden his unique perspective about this dispute. The views expressed here are the author's
personal views and do not necessarily reflect those of the Department of Defense, the United
States Army, the United States Military Academy, or any other department or agency of the
United States Government.
   1 See, e.g., Sven Milekic & Maja Zivanovic, Border Disputes Still Bedevil Ex-Yugoslav
States, BALKAN INSIGHT (July 3, 2017), https://balkaninsight.com/2017/07/03/border-
disputes-still-bedevil-most-ex-yugoslav-states-07-01-2017-1/; Marja Novak, Slovenia to Sue
Fellow  EU   Member Croatia Over Border Ruling, REUTERS, June 18, 2018,
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-slovenia-croatia-border/slovenia-to-sue-fellow-eu-
member-croatia-over-border-ruling-idUSKBN1JE1PP; Slovenian Press Agency (STA),
Slovenia, Croatia Attend ECJfor Border Arbitration Hearing, TOTAL SLOVENIA NEWS (July
13, 2019, 11:39 AM), https://www.total-slovenia-news.com/politics/4090-slovenia-croatia-
attend-ecj-for-border-arbitration-hearing.
   2 See Figure 1 infra note 76.
   3 See, e.g., Slovenia - Croatia Boundary Dispute, MARBDY CONSULTING (Oct. 15, 2018),
http://www.marbdy.com/slovenia-croatia-arbitration/.