About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



38 Jurimetrics 23 (1997-1998)
Creating a Clone in Ninety Days: In Search of a Cloning Policy

handle is hein.journals/juraba38 and id is 33 raw text is: CREATING A CLONE IN NINETY DAYS:
IN SEARCH OF A CLONING POLICY
Andrea L. Bonnicksen*
Mary had a little lamb
She cloned it from a ewe
The lamb, confused, [did ask] the sheep
Am I me or you? I
This apocryphal lamb's confusion is but one perplexity in the aftermath of
Dolly's birth. For the first time in the era of new reproductive technologies, a
research development has directed attention straight to the legislatures. The
impulse to enact prohibitive laws at the front end of medicine contrasts to the
usual process in which ethical and legal deliberation come first and lawmaking
later, if at all. With Dolly's birth, however, a Presidential decree, mobilization of
a national advisory board, a dozen state bills, and three Congressional bills
followed with headturning efficiency.
Intense governmental interest in a technique used successfully once in a
mammal is unprecedented. Alexander Capron's observation that [many of the
issues in cloning are uncharted2 holds true for policy as well as ethics. To be
sure, cloning an adult's genome through somatic cell nuclear transfer has much
to condemn it and very little, if anything, to defend it. But to mandate a prior
restraint on a speculative technique, under a false sense of urgency, is to invite
* Andrea L. Bonnicksen is Professor and Chair, Department of Political Science, Northern
Illinois University. She teaches courses in biomedical and biotechnology policy and writes primarily
in the area of reproductive and genetic technologies.
1. Peter & Lin Scares, Metropolitan Diary, N.Y. TIMES, Mar. 12, 1997, at C2.
2. Alexander Morgan Capron, Inside the Beltway Again: A Sheep of a Different Feather, 7
KENNEDY INST. ETHICS J. 171, 173 (1997).

FALL 1997