About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



19 J. Transnat'l L. & Pol'y 281 (2009-2010)
The Dilemma of Direct Participation in Hostilities

handle is hein.journals/jtrnlwp19 and id is 285 raw text is: THE DILEMMA OF DIRECT PARTICIPATION
IN HOSTILITIES
ERIC CHRISTENSEN*
A universal and comprehensive definition of direct participation
in hostilities (DPH) does not exist. Furthermore, modern warfare's
tendency to blur the distinction between combatant and civilian ne-
cessitates a new interpretation of DPH. However, States have incen-
tives to pursue narrow or broad interpretations of DPH, or even
both. These contradictory strategies create a dilemma for policy-
makers who seek to reinterpret the concept of DPH. Any revision is
likely to put some group of individuals at risk; there is not a simple
answer to the question of how to best revise DPH. Instead, a dra-
matic revision of DPH is needed. This Essay will briefly examine
the law of armed conflict before exploring the merits of the interpre-
tations of DPH adopted by the United States, Israel, and the Inter-
national Committee of the Red Cross. Lastly, this essay will rec-
ommend a potential solution to the dilemma of DPH interpretation:
a limited membership- based approach.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION           ...................................... ....... 282
I.     THE LAW OF ARMED CONFLICT AND DIRECT PARTICIPATION
IN HOSTILITIES                    ..................................... 285
A. A Brief Summary of the Law of Armed Conflict......... 285
B. Direct Participation in Hostilities....        ........... 287
II.    THE U.S. INTERPRETATION OF DIRECT PARTICIPATION IN
HOSTILITIES.       ................................. ....... 290
A. Counterterrorism Operations                 ........... ....... 290
B. Military Contractors and Civilian Employees............ 294
C. Conclusion          ..........................    ..... 298
III.   THE ISRAELI INTERPRETATION OF DIRECT PARTICIPATION
IN HOSTILITIES        ............................... ...... 299
A. Historical Background        ...............       ....... 300
B. The PCATI v. Israel Decision     ............      ...... 300
C. Conclusion         ............................... 304
* The author would like to thank Professor Frank Gavin of the University of Texas
Lyndon B. Johnson School of Public Affairs and Professors Derek Jinks and Robert Chesney
of the University of Texas School of Law, whose efforts and ideas have made this essay far
better. However, all remaining errors are solely that of the author. I would also like to
thank Kelly Stephenson for his generosity and help and Kate Doty for her editorial eye.
Lastly, I would like to thank my wife, Laura Christensen, for graciously undertaking the
lion's share of our wedding planning while I worked on this essay.
281