About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



1 Colum. J. Race & L. 187 (2011-2012)
Protecting Plyler: New Challenges to the Right of Immigrant Children to Access a Public School Education

handle is hein.journals/cjoral1 and id is 194 raw text is: PROTECTING PLYLER:
NEW CHALLENGES TO THE RIGHT OF
IMMIGRANT CHILDREN TO ACCESS A PUBLIC
SCHOOL EDUCATION
Udi Ofer
Thirty jears ago, the Supreme Court ruled in Plyler v. Doe that
undocumented children have the same ri ht to access a public school education as
children who are United States citiZens or immigrant children law/fuly admitted
to the United States. Yet today, undocumented children still face numerous
obstacles when attempting to access a public school education. Moreover, new
questions have arisen about the ri ht of children on nonimmgrant visas to enroll
in school. This Article reviews the Plyler decision and subsequent attempts to
reverse the ruling. The Article examines the rise of the modern-da movement to
restrict immigration and the impact of this movement on the rght of immigrant
children to access a public school education.  The Article considers several
examples of school districts preventing immigrant children from enrolling in
school, and argues that children on nonimmigrant B visas should not be denied
enrollment. Finaly, the Article concludes by recommending numerous steps Jr
the federal government to take to ensure that school districts provide equal access
to an education to all immigrant children.
INTRODUCTION            ................................................ 188
1.  TIE SUPREME CouRi's LAND\L\RK PLYLER DECISION.......... 189
II. SuBSI QuLINT ElFORTS TO CHf-IAL INGI PLYLER AND ENsuING
POLITICAL TENSION         ...........................     ........195
III. LoCAL AND STAIE AiTIEMPiS To PREN ENT AND DETER
IMMIGRANT STUDENi ENROLLMEN ............            ............. 204
A. Schools Mandating or Requesting Proof of Immigration
Status During Enrollment.      ....................  .......204
B. Nonimmigrant Children and School Enrollment..............211
Udi Ofer is the Advocacy Director of the New York Civil Liberties Union
(NYCLU). He is also an adjunct professor at New York Law School. Udi
thanks Donna Lieberman, Adriana Pifi6n, Shira Roza, Clare Tarpey, Jennifer
Carnig, and ilichael Tan for their work to protect the civil rights of immigrant
New Yorkers, and to ensure that every child in New York State has access to a
public school education.