About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



81 Calif. L. Rev. 61 (1993)
Mandatory Sentencing Laws: Undermining the Effectiveness of Determinate Sentencing Reform

handle is hein.journals/calr81 and id is 79 raw text is: Mandatory Sentencing Laws:
Undermining the Effectiveness of
Determinate Sentencing Reform
Gary T. Lowenthalt
Recent years have seen significant changes in sentencing law: deter-
minate sentencing schemes and mandatory enhanced sentences have
largely displaced discretionary sentencing regimes operating within broad
sentencing constraints. Commentators have variously lamented and
applauded the advent of both determinate sentencing and mandatory pen-
alties, yet the interaction of these two innovations has been left largely
unexamined. Professor Lowenthal provides an analysis of the perverse
consequences that ensue when sentencing, guidelines are paired with
mandatory sentencing: the very consistency and proportionality that these
changes were supposed to engender can be undercut when the two sentenc-
ing approaches are combined. Mandatory sentencing emphasizes a single
aggravating factor, contrary to determinate sentencing, which directs
judges to a whole complex offactors. Mandatory sentencing also is applied
unevenly, with those exercising their right to trial often receiving harsher
penalties. Thus, a factor that should not be detrimental under determi-
nate sentencing, such as exercising one's constitutional right to trial, is
detrimental under mandatory sentencing. In sum, the goals of determi-
nate sentencing-consistent punishment for like crimes and proportional
punishment for different crimes-are greatly undermined by mandatory
sentencing. Professor Lowenthal concludes by arguing for legislative
changes to ameliorate the harsh and undesired effects of mandatory sen-
tencing measures.
Two developments in the last twenty years have transformed felony
sentencing in the United States. First, most jurisdictions have adopted
determinate sentencing schemes that narrow the range of sanctions avail-
able to trial courts and reduce or eliminate the broad discretion previ-
ously exercised by corrections administrators and parole boards.1 At the
t Professor of Law, Arizona State University. A.B. 1966, Harvard University; J.D. 1969,
University of Chicago. I wish to thank Jane Aiken, David Kaye, Ilene Nagel, Stephen Schulhofer,
and Jim Weinstein, whose wise suggestions improved earlier drafts of this paper. Jennie Gorrell,
Randall Hodgkinson, and Janissa Strabuk provided valuable research assistance.
1. Under indeterminate sentencing systems that previously existed, legislatures established
broad parameters of permissible punishment for each offense category. Penalties ranged from no