About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



30 U. Fla. L. Rev. 94 (1977-1978)
A Review of Judicial Exceptions to the Kirby Lumber Rule

handle is hein.journals/uflr30 and id is 108 raw text is: A REVIEW OF JUDICIAL EXCEPTIONS
TO THE KIRBY LUMBER RULE
INTRODUCTION
The liberal use of derogatory superlatives by commentators discussing
cancellation of indebtedness income imparts a clear impression of the state of
the tax law in that area. They remark, for example, that [e]ven the most rabid
dialectition of federal tax law would readily concede that logic has taken an
extended vacation in the debt cancellation area,1 that the development of
the law of debt cancellation is highly inadequate,''2 and that it is one of the
murkiest pools of obscurity in the tax law.3
Numerous reasons exist for this difficulty. A fundamental problem is that
income has not been adequately defined either in an economic sense4 or in
the federal tax usage.5 The statutory definition provides that gross income
means all income from whatever source derived, including . . . [i]ncome from
I. Eustice, Cancellation of Indebtedness and the Federal Income Tax: A Problem of
Creeping Confusion, 14 TAX L. REv. 225, 286 (1959).
2. Surrey & Warren, The Income Tax Project of the American Law Institute: Gross In-
come, Deductions, Accounting, Gains and Losses, Cancellation of Indebtedness, 66 HARV. L.
REV. 761, 815 (1953).
3. Eustice, supra note I, at 225.
4. Economists have variously defined income as a service-flow in consumption, as re-
current receipts, as the net addition to an individual's economic power with a specified
period of time, 0. BROWNLEE & E. ALLEN, ECONOMICS OF PUBLIC FINANCE 243 (2d ed. 1954),
or as the algebraic sum of (1) the market value of rights exercised in consumption and
(2) the change in the value of the store of property rights between the beginning and end
of the period in question. H. SIVIANS, PERSONAL INCOME TAXATION 50 (1938).
The service-flow concept includes goods and services consumed in money value and in
the estimated money value of unpaid labor. This would appear to include money borrowed
when it was consumed and would not include discharge of a debt which had previously been
consumed. The recurrent receipts definition would not include debt discharge presumably
for the likelihood of its non-recurrence. The net accretion concept comes close to the incre-
ment in assets theory used by courts in this area but its failings lie in the absence of a
given time period for computation and in the lack of specificity for determining net assets,
i.e.: Is one's self an asset that increases in value when it becomes trained or educated? The
algebraic sum theory would apparently combine consumption and net accretion in assets,
thus retaining the problems with respect to debt cancellation mentioned above. Economists
leave the field insisting income is gain, whether viewed as the personal ability to spend
in a period of time, or the net accumulation of capital or consumable assets; the difficulty
remains-what do we count when we compute gain? These definitions of course look to
what should, in the opinion of each advocate, constitute income, but, such considerations
are relevant when the proposed legislation in this area is evaluated. See 0. BROWNLEE & E.
ALLEN, supra at 242-47; H. SIMONS, supra at 50-51.
5. There remains the larger question whether the statutory exclusions and specialized
treatment of certain items plus the judicial and administrative rules developed for certain
particular categories of receipts permit the formulation of a definition of 'income.' . . . Is
it perhaps necessary to a sound income tax that the content of 'income' should remain
essentially fluid, so that the application of the tax can keep pace with changing conditions?
S. SURREY, W. WARREN, P. MCDANIEL, & H. AULT, FEDERAL INCOME TAXATION 115 (1972).