About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



49 Rutgers Computer & Tech. L.J. 207 (2022-2023)
Forget the Facts, Aim for the Rights! On the Obsolescence of Empirical Knowledge in Defining the Risk/Rights-Based Approach to AI Regulation in the European Union

handle is hein.journals/rutcomt49 and id is 227 raw text is: 





FORGET   THE FACTS,  AIM  FOR THE  RIGHTS!


    ON THE  OBSOLESCENCE OF EMPIRICAL KNOWLEDGE IN
    DEFINING   THE  RISK/RIGHTS-BASED APPROACH TO Al
            REGULATION IN   THE  EUROPEAN   UNION

         Ljupcho  Grozdanovski,* J6rume  De  Cooman**

                           Abstract

    This article critically examines the inception of the recent
European  Commission  (EC) proposal for a regulation laying down
harmonization  rules  for Artificial Intelligence (Al Act).  By
establishing a four-level taxonomy of AI-related risks (non-high,
limited, high, unacceptable) and corresponding technical standards,
this instrument aims at preventing the occurrence of risks caused, in
particular, by so-called high-risk Al systems. Though by virtue of its
purpose and  design, the Al Act follows a risk-based approach to
regulation, it displays a specificity when compared to existing risk
regulation in the European Union (EU), in such areas as environment
and health. This specificity stems from the operative definition of
risk the Al Act relies on: the risks covered in this proposal are not
scientifically measurable threats of physical harm but threats of
human  rights violations which are difficult to quantify. In light of
this, this article raises the issue of the evidence, if any, the EC
gathered in view of designing a proportionate (i.e., reality conform)
regulatory framework  on  Al. Through  a critical analysis of the
discovery procedures (public consultations) the EC launched for the
purpose of drafting the AI Act, this article finds that the Commission
disregarded the  evidence gathered on  several important points,
namely  the type (horizontal or sectoral) of regulation best suited for
AI-related risk prevention. Considering  the  limited impact  of
empirical knowledge  on the design of the Al Act, this article seeks
to determine if, in lieu of being a normative response to factual
reality, the instrument under consideration gives specific normative

* Permanent Research Associate, Belgian Foundation for Scientific Research
(FNRS), University of Liege.
* Ph.D Candidate and Research Assistant, University of Liege.