About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



30 Melb. U. L. Rev. 191 (2006)
The Impact of Coleman v Power on the Policing Defence and Sentencing of Public Nuisance Cases in Queensland

handle is hein.journals/mulr30 and id is 197 raw text is: THE IMPACT OF COLEMAN vPOWER ON THE
POLICING, DEFENCE AND SENTENCING OF PUBLIC
NUISANCE CASES IN QUEENSLAND
TAMARA WALSH*
[The High Court s decision in Coleman v Power promised to provide the many defendants charged
with offensive language, offensive behaviour and public nuisance with a means of contesting their
charge. The majority of the Court stated that the purpose of such offences was to maintain public
order and to protect the public from harm, and they interpreted the scope of such offences relatively
narrowly. Therefore, it was expected that the policing, defence and sentencing of 'offensive'
defendants would have changed since Coleman v Power was handed down. To test this assumption,
the outcomes of public nuisance cases in Brisbane and Townsville in July 2005 (10 months after
Coleman v Power) were compared with those from July 2004 (two months before Coleman v Power).
It was found that while more public nuisance defendants were contesting their charge(s), more
people were being charged with the offence, that situations leading to a charge did not accord with
the standard of seriousness established in Coleman v Power, and that sentencing outcomes were no
different. Thus, it appears that Coleman v Power is not being followed at the 'ground level' of
policing, defending and sentencing public nuisance cases in Queensland]
CONTENTS
I    Introdu ction  .............................................................................................................  19 1
1I   The  Decision  of the  Court in  Coleman  ................................................................... 193
A   O verv iew   .................................................................................................... 193
B   The  Purpose  of the  O ffence ........................................................................ 195
C   The  Scope of the Offence .............. . ...................... ............................ 197
D   Police  and  Public  Order Offences ................................ .........................  198
III  E m pirical  Study  ...................................................................................................... 199
A   Rationale, M ethodology  and  Hypotheses .................................................. 199
B   Findings regarding the Policing of Public Nuisance .................................. 201
1  The Number of Public Nuisance Charges ................................... 201
2   The Basis for Public Nuisance Charges ........................................ 202
3   Offensive Conduct Directed at Police Officers ............................. 206
C   Findings regarding the Defence of Public Nuisance Charges .................... 206
D   Findings Related to the Outcomes of Public Nuisance Prosecutions ........ 208
IV   C onclusion  .............................................................................................................. 209
I INTRODUCTION
In September 2004, the High Court handed down its decision in Cole-
man v Power,' a case that examined the relationship between insulting language
BSW (Hons), LLB (UNSW), PhD (QUT); Lecturer, TC Beirne School of Law, The University
of Queensland. I extend my sincere thanks to research assistants Tara Kennedy, Jennifer Samiec,
Larissa Evans, Shaun Gordon, Sarah Mizrahi and Michelle Pilbeam for their contribution to this
research.
(2004) 220 CLR I ('Coleman').