About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



39 B.U. Int'l L.J. 181 (2021)
Replacing God with Big Data: Personalizing Copyright Law

handle is hein.journals/builj39 and id is 193 raw text is: REPLACING GOD WITH BIG DATA:
PERSONALIZING COPYRIGHT LAW
Ayelet Hoffmann Libson* & Adi Libson**
ABSTRACT
Can religious law serve as a source of inspiration for a modern legal
system? As all religious legal systems, Jewish law includes statutes that rely
on a premise of divine omniscience. By assuming a worldview in which God
sees into the human heart, Jewish law can allow for subjective and
personalized legal norms that derive from individuals' assessments of value
or need. Ostensibly, the centrality of divine omniscience in enabling such
laws renders them irrelevant to a secular legal system. This article highlights
how, surprisingly, the legal structure of these norms may nonetheless be a
fruitful source of inspiration for a modern legal system. The article focuses
on the Jewish legal model of personalized copyright, and demonstrates how
this model could be applied in modern secular law by replacing the function
of the belief in divine omniscience with the use of big data.
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................... 182
I. PERSONALIZATION IN JEWISH LAW ....................................................... 186
II. THE PROBLEM OF COPYRIGHT IN JEWISH LAW .................................... 189
A. Models of Copyright Protection ................................................ 190
B. Contemporary Problems and the Solution of Personalized
Law.......................................................................................... 198
III. CAN PERSONALIZED COPYRIGHT LAW BE APPLIED IN A MODERN
LEGAL CONTEXT? .......................................................................... 201
A. Personalization and the Generality of the Law ......................... 202
B. Personalization of Copyright Without God? ............................. 204
CONCLUSION ............................................................................................. 205
* Assistant Professor, Interdisciplinary Center, Herzliya. Ph.D., New York University; B.A.
Hebrew University.
** Associate Professor, Bar-Ilan University. Ph.D., Bar-Ilan University; LL.M., New York
University, LL.B., Hebrew University; B.A., Hebrew University. We thank Liel Cohen for
research assistance.

181