About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



14 Wyo. L. Rev. 161 (2014)
Criminal Law - Prejudiced by the Prejudice Prong: Proposing a New Standard for Ineffective Assistance Counsel in Wyoming after Osborne v. State, 2012 WY 123, 285 P.3d 248 (Wyo. 2012)

handle is hein.journals/wylr14 and id is 171 raw text is: CASE NOTE

CRIMINAL LAW-Prejudiced by the Prejudice Prong: Proposing a
New Standard for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel in Wyoming after
Osborne v. State, 2012 WY 123, 285 P.3d 248 (Wyo. 2012)
Kellsief Nienhuser*
[T]here is no right more essential than the right to the assistance
of counsel.'
INTRODUCTION
The Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution guarantees the
accused the right to assistance of counsel in all criminal prosecutions.2 The
purpose of the right to counsel is to ensure criminal defendants receive a fair trial.'
Unfortunately, that essential right appears to be mere dicta when it comes to the
judicial system's treatment of ineffective assistance of counsel claims.'
In 2012, the Wyoming Supreme Court evaluated whether a Sheridan resident
was denied his Sixth Amendment right to assistance of counsel at his murder trial.
In Osborne v. State, Shawn Osborne appealed his first degree murder conviction,
arguing that his trial counsel was ineffective.' The Wyoming Supreme Court used
the oft-cited standard found in Strickland v. Washington to evaluate the claim.
Under Strickland, the defendant must show both that counsel's performance
was deficient and that the deficient performance prejudiced the defense.7 The
* J.D. Candidate, University of Wyoming College of Law, 2015. I would like to first and
foremost thank my parents, Greg and Jodie, and my sisters, Jaclyn, Jessica, and Lexie, for their
endless love and support. Thank you to Professor Darrell Jackson, Brian Fuller, Julianne Gern,
Lucas Wallace, and the rest of the Wyoming Law Review Board for their advice and guidance
throughout the writing process. Special thanks to Katie Koski for encouraging me to write for the
Wyoming Law Review and David Singleton for his invaluable input on this topic.
I Lakeside v. Oregon, 435 U.S. 333, 341 (1978).
2 U.S. CONsT. amend. VI.
See, e.g., Lockhart v. Fretwell, 506 U.S. 364, 368 (1993); Nix v. Whiteside, 475 U.S. 157,
178 (1986); Daniel Dinger, Successive Interviews and Successful Prosecutions: The Interplay ofthe Sixth
Amendment Right to Counsel and the Dual Sovereignty Doctrine in a Post-Cobb World, 40 TEX. TECH
L. REV. 917, 921 (2008).
David L. Bazelon, The Defective Assistance of Counsel, 42 U. CIN. L. REv. 1, 22-23 (1973)
(I have often been told that if my court were to reverse every case in which there was inadequate
counsel, we would have to send back half the convictions in my jurisdiction.).
1 2012 WY 123, 5 18, 285 P.3d 248, 252 (Wyo. 2012).
6 466 U.S. 668, 687 (1984).
7 Id.