About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



2 Charleston L. Rev. 215 (2007-2008)
Time to Close the Collection Agency: Addressing the Abuse of Bad Check Laws

handle is hein.journals/charlwrev2 and id is 225 raw text is: TIME TO CLOSE THE COLLECTION AGENCY:
ADDRESSING THE ABUSE OF BAD CHECK
LAWS
Elwood Earl Sanders, Jr., Esq.*
I. A Review of the Pertinent Aspects of State Criminal Laws
Governing   Bad  Checks  ....................................................... 217
II. The Present Criminal Bad Check Scheme Discriminates
Against the Poor and Favors the Rich ............................... 219
III. Inferences or Prima Facie Evidence of Guilt Arising
From Nonpayment Ought to Violate Due Process as
Irrational or Impermissible Burden-Shifting to the
A ccu sed  ................................................................................ 222
IV. The Prosecutor as a Collection Agency ................................. 223
V. Abusive Debt Collection   Practices .......................................... 232
VI. There is Not an Effective Civil Sanction in Most States ...... 233
VII. A Proposed Civil Sanction for Bad Checks .......................... 236
V III.  C onclusion  ........................................................................... 237
IX . A ppen dix  ................................................................................. 239
I assert a bold proposal: Our criminal bad check laws, as
written and implemented, imprison for debt and burden the poor.
I agree that the writer of a dishonored check should honor that
*Elwood Earl Sanders, Jr., Esq., J.D. 1983 University of Alabama. Adjunct
Assistant Professor, School of Continuing Studies, University of Richmond.
Sanders is an Appellate Procedure Consultant with Lantagne Legal Printing in
Richmond, Virginia. He was an associate with the Framme Law Firm in
Richmond, Virginia from 2000 to 2007.
This article is respectfully dedicated to the Honorable William R. Murphy, Chief
Judge, General District Court, Prince William County (retired). Judge Murphy
was a valuable mentor in the early days of my practice. I recall his thundering
at an absent merchant, who had presumably received payment on a bad check,
that the misuse of the criminal justice system to collect civil debts was
malicious prosecution. I do not imply Judge Murphy would agree with the
conclusions of this article, but I owe him a debt that I could never repay, with a
check or otherwise. I also want to express a special appreciation to Timothy
Martin, Esq., Eldon Donny Meeks, Esq., and Steven Burt, Esq. of the
Mississippi Bar for their encouragement.

215