About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



1 Annette Schaper, Universalization of Comprehensive Safeguards - Next Steps 1 (2012)

handle is hein.unl/unisafe0001 and id is 1 raw text is: Universalization of Comprehensive
Safeguards-Next Steps
February 201 2
Annette Schaper
Peace Research Institute Frankfurt
Introduction
On 28 May 2010, the NPT Review Conference was able to adopt by consensus
a final document. The most important part of the document contains a list of
63 actions to which the parties have committed themselves. The next Review
Conference will examine whether and to what extent these actions have been
implemented. The actions cover a wide range of tasks from the three pillars
of the NPT-namely nuclear disarmament, nuclear non-proliferation and the
peaceful uses of nuclear energy. The old problem of perceived injustice because
of inherent discrimination in the NPT will be re-examined by accounting for the
implementation of the three sets of actions. It is therefore important to achieve
successes in all three pillars. This paper deals mainly with Action 29 which
appears under the headline of non-proliferation:
Action 29: The Conference encourages IAEA to further facilitate and assist
the States parties in the conclusion and entry into force of comprehensive
safeguards agreements and additional protocols. The Conference calls
on States parties to consider specific measures that would promote the
universalization of the comprehensive safeguards agreements.
Although assigned to the non-proliferation set, universalization of comprehensive
safeguards would also strengthen the nuclear disarmament component. Universal
safeguards and steps that facilitate their implementation have many advantages
and only one disadvantage, namely higher costs and more funding for the IAEA.
But these costs are marginal in comparison to what some states spend for their
security.
In the following, I want to discuss the advantages of universal safeguards, the
commitments that have been made so far, and the steps that are necessary to
achieve this goal.
Benefits of Universal Comprehensive Safeguards
Delegates from nuclear-weapon states claim that it would be a waste of effort to
invest in comprehensive safeguards in nuclear-weapon states, who are allowed
to use fissile material for any purpose, including nuclear weapons. But the
universalization of comprehensive safeguards would have several benefits.