About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline

LOG IN
LOG IN


112 W. Va. L. Rev. 1 (2009-2010)

handle is hein.journals/wvb112 and id is 1 raw text is: VIRTUAL RULE OF LAW Michael Risch* I. IN TR O D U CTION ........................................................................................1 II. VIRTUAL WORLDS AND DIGITAL ENTREPRENEURSHIP ........................... 4 III. THE RULE OF LAW AND VIRTUAL ECONOMIES .................................. 8 A. The Tie between Law and Virtual Business ............................ 8 B. Defining the Rule of Law ..................................................... 12 C. Liberty and the Rule of Law ................................................ 16 IV. DEFINING LAW IN RULE OF LAW ................................................... 23 V . VIRTUAL RULE OF LAW ...................................................................... 27 A. Market Regulation Via the User Agreement ......................... 27 1. Contract Modification ............................................ 28 2. V agueness ................................................................ 3 1 3. Lack of Enforceability and Enforcement ................ 32 B. Community Norms as Law ................................................... 33 C . Fact-F inding ........................................................................ 36 D . C ode as Law ......................................................................... 37 1. Code and the Rule of Law ....................................... 37 2. The Interaction between Code and Agreements .......... 39 E. Legislated Lawlessness and the Rules of the Game . ............ 41 F. Legislated Rules and the Magic Circle ................................. 42 1. In- W orld Legislation ............................................... 43 2. Importation of Real-world Law .............................. 45 G. Jurisdiction and Real-World Law ........................................ 48 V I. C ON CLU SION ...................................................................................... 50 I. INTRODUCTION The rule of law generally requires that governments announce and fol- low the laws of the land. This allows citizens to know what to expect from their government and to make investments accordingly.1 Business also relies on the ©02009 by Michael Risch. This Article is an expanded version of the author's presentation at the WEST VIRGINIA LAW REVIEW'S symposium on Digital Entrepreneurship. The author thanks participants in that symposium, as well as Joshua Fairfield. Eric Goldman, James Grimmelman. Greg Lastowka. Anne Lofaso, Brian Tamanaha. Francis Taney. and Tim Wu for their helpful comments. Helpful research assistance was provided by Nate Griffith. 1 JOHN RAWLS, A THEORY OF JUSTICE 235 (1971) (A legal system is a coercive order of pub- lic rules addressed to rational persons for the purpose of regulating their conduct and providing the framework for social cooperation. When these rules are just they establish a basis for legiti- mate expectations.).