About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



4 Prof. Law. 1 (1992-1993)

handle is hein.journals/proflw4 and id is 1 raw text is: 

THE



PROFESSIONAL



LA           WY                ER                 November 1992 Vol. 4, No. 1

Standing Committee on Professionalism
American Bar Association Center for Professional Responsibility


Monitoring for Recovery


from Substance Abuse


by Ruth Woodruff

  Having someone monitor your
progress may not strike everyone
as a pleasant prospect, but when
the choice is between losing one's
life or livelihood versus having
someone look over a shoulder
now and then, the option of being
monitored may not seem so bad
after all.
  With increasing frequency,
lawyers who have been involved
in misconduct related to chemical
addiction are being given the op-
portunity to enter into recovery and
maintain their law practices under
the careful watch of recovery
monitors. Lawyers who would
otherwise be suspended from the
practice of law or would continue
in a downward spiral toward
destruction of self and harm to the
public are able to regain their
health and, at the same time, main-
tain their law practices. This article
will outline several recovery
monitoring programs and discuss
the desirability of recovery monitor-
ing of lawyers.
  Monitoring programs are struc-
tured in various ways. One type is
disciplinary probation monitoring
where supervision of a lawyer is a
condition of probation imposed by
the court after a disciplinary


proceeding. The second type of
program is known as diversion,
where the goal is to divert a
lawyer with a substance abuse
problem into an agency or group
where help is available before his
addiction results in a serious dis-
ciplinary violation. The Honorable
Donna L Cervini, an associate
judge in Cook County Circuit Court
in Illinois and a member of the
ABA's Commission on Impaired At-
torneys, explains that in both types
of programs, the goal is to protect
     w


 that  otnl       evni

 Stanfdin~g     be-':_ 3 ,

 tween me :and:

 thafe`Fdrugsr   isX that   =

 I'm,  goingtodrbpl

 a  -urine   sample.

 ThanikGodfor

 thiat.  Whatever:it:

 takes.'


the public, to ensure recovery of
the impaired lawyer, and to assist
the lawyer in resuming full time
practice.
How   Monitoring   Works
  According to Judge Cervini,
the keys to the success of any
monitoring program, whether diver-
sion or disciplinary probation, are
the individuals selected to serve
as monitors and how informed
they are about the issues involved.
She explains that monitors in both
diversion and probation monitoring
must be fully trained regarding al-
cohol and drug addiction, be able
to detect a relapse, be equipped
to deal with relapse effectively
and compassionately, and be able
to demonstrate a good sense of
judgment. In an ideal program,
Judge Cervini.maintains, monitors
would be continually retrained,
and given on-going support them-
selves.
  Monitoring programs vary from
state to state. Some are an in-
tegral part of a very formalized
disciplinary structure, others are
less institutionalized programs that
operate on an informal basis, still
others are in the very beginning
stages of development. How
(Continued on Page 4.)