About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



24 Or. Rev. Int'l L. 1 (2023)

handle is hein.journals/porril24 and id is 1 raw text is: 











ARTICLES



GEORGE   P. SMITH, 11*



       Restricting Scientific Legitimacy in the

                  Age   of Biotechnology?

Abstract................................................................................................ 2
I.     Introduction and Overview: Containing Technology ........... 3
II.    Shaping Policy .....................................................................  6
       A.  Good  or Evil Consequences?...................................... 10
       B . W hole Science ............................................................  12
       C . Junk Science ...............................................................   12
III.   The Science of the Coronavirus Pandemic: A Case in Point.. 15
IV.    A New  EPA  Regulation: Toward an Ethic of Protection........ 17
V .    G enetic M odifications........................................................  18
VI.    Codifying an Ethic of Care: International and Domestic
       G uidelines ...................................................................... . .  2 1
       A . International G uidance.....................................................21
       B . D om estic A ction ........................................................ 22
VII.   The Precautionary Principle: An Ethic of Restraint or of
       P recaution ? ...................................................................... . .   23
       A.  Judicial Recognition of the Precautionary Principle .......26
       B.  Geopolitics and the Precautionary Principle................27
VIII.  The Outreach of Daubert and Scientific Evidence: Judicial
       B efuddlem ent ......................................................................  28
       A.  Alternative Approaches to Judicial Decision-Making..... 31
       B.  Participatory Democracy: Educating the Public.......... 32
C on clu sion  ................................................................................... . .  34


   * Professor Emeritus of Law, The Catholic University of America, Washington, D.C.,
Resident Fellow, The Institute for Advanced Study, Indiana University, Bloomington,
Indiana. Points of Contact: smithg@cua.edu, 202-319-5162, Washington, D.C.


[ll