About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



16 J. Pol. Stud. 1 (2009)

handle is hein.journals/jlo16 and id is 1 raw text is: 




Pak-Iran  Relations  in the Post-Imperial   World


                             Dr. Lubna Abid  Ali

                                  Abstract

       The  continuing interaction between  the peoples  of Iran and
       Pakistan is centuries old. It has its roots in historical, cultural
       and  lingual affinity. 'From the time of first sustained Muslim
       influences', states Howard  Wriggins, 'the models  for political
       structure and  processes  as well as  religious inspiration and
       cultural influences came  from Iran and  not the Arab  Middle
       East.' The  trajectory of Iran - Pakistan relations has been
       shared by not only the domestic and regional dynamics but also
       due  to the impact of global correlation of forces. As the title
       indicates, this paper is an attempt to analyze the situation of
       Pakistan-Iran relations in the post-imperial world.

Background   of the Issue

Before proceeding  to the main discussion of this issue it would be appropriate
to mention  here the pertinent observation of Gearge  Nethaniel Curzon  who
says:  'Turkestan, Afghanistan, Transcaspia,  Persia to  many  these  names
breathe  only  a  sense   of  utter remoteness   or  a  memory   of  strange
vicissitudes.... To me  I confess, they are the pieces of a chessboard  upon
which  is being played out a game  for the domination of the world.'2 Iran and
Pakistan are thus located astride the two great energy routes of the world, i.e.,
The  Persian Gulf - Caspian Sea, and Makran  Coast, sea lanes of Arabian Sea
connected  with  Indian Ocean.   As  reflected above, this study  charts the
evolution  of Pakistan-Iran  relations through  several  phases;   the  1979
revolution, Iran-Iraq war, Afghan war, US intervention in Afghanistan, Khatami's
civilizational, discourse, Iran-India-Pakistan gas pipeline project, Iran's nuclear
stand off and the role of regional and global powers.

In the 19th century, the British defined Persian question in terms of the decline
of imperial Iranian state and the  management   of that decline. The  Iranian
question facing the US in the 21st century is that of the birth of modern Iranian
state and its reemergence  as  a regional power. The  Iranian question in the
context of Pakistan's interaction is about a relationship and its transformation.
Thus, in this perspective, the underlying assumptions of critical theory3 with its

  Howard Wriggins, Changing Power Relations between the Middle East and South,
Orbis (Fall 1976): p. 787.
2George N. Curzon, Persia and the Persian Question, Vol. 1 (Frank Cass: London,
1966), pp. 3-4.
3 Jennifer Sterling Folker (ed.), Making Sense of International Relations Theory, (New
Delhi: Via Publishers, 2007), p.158.