About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



2015 In-House Persp. [1] (2015)

handle is hein.journals/inhouse11 and id is 1 raw text is: An undeclared conflict of interest
IHP Home (/IHP.aspx) News (/IHP_news.aspx) Features (/IHP_features.aspx) Opinion
(/IHPopinion.aspx) Film (/IHP_video.aspx)  Archive
(/Publications/publications_inhouseperspective.aspx)
Dina Medland argues that combining the role of general
counsel and company secretary could be more trouble than it's
worth.
A potential conflict of interest is sitting quietly in many boardrooms, just waiting to explode
into a corporate governance disaster. It is the practice of allowing the same individual to hold
the title of both general counsel (GC) and company secretary.
It's a fairly common phenomenon. For example, at the end of July this year, Rentokil plc announced that Paul
Griffiths was stepping down as company secretary after a staggering 35 years of service. He is succeeded by Daragh
Fagan, Group General Counsel, who has taken on the 'additional responsibility of company secretary', according to
the announcement.
John McAdam, Rentokil Chairman said: 'I'm delighted that Daragh will be taking over the Company Secretary role
supporting the board.' However, that brief phrase highlights exactly where the seeds of conflict lie.
The first consideration when taking on any dual role is over how to allocate sufficient time to each area of
responsibility. In the case of Rentokil, if 75 per cent of Fagan's time is spent on being general counsel, that leaves
relatively little time to devote to being an effective company secretary.
A dual role may offer the opportunity for the GC to attend board meetings. However, a GC would attend those
meetings in a different capacity to the company secretary: the GC usually reports to the chief executive, whereas
the company secretary reports to the chairman.
While all UK plcs are required to have a company secretary, the role itself varies enormously, and is changing rapidly.
A recent collaborative study (https://www.icsa.org.uk/products-and-services/knowledge-and-
guidance/research/the-company-secretary-report) between the Institute of Chartered Secretaries and
Administrators (ICSA) and Henley Business School highlights the evolution of the role through discussing it with
those at the coalface.
'I think as general counsel you are heavily involved in the running of the business and are the chief executive's right
hand. I don't think that's compatible with (being the) company secretary, where you should be (the) Chairman's
right hand' said report participant.