About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



15 GlobCon 1 (2026)

handle is hein.journals/globc15 and id is 1 raw text is: 


Global Constitutionalism (2026), 15: 1, 1-10                             CAMBRIDGE
doi:10.1017/S2045381726100227                                            UNIVERSITY PRESS

EDITORIAL


Global constitutionalism and/as enlightenment

Jared Holley', Antje Wiener2'3, Andrea Birdsall' , Stephanie Law4 , Susan Kang;   and
Jo Shaw6

'School of Social and Political Science, University of Edinburgh, UK; 2Department of Political Science &
Department of Law, University of Hamburg, Germany; 3Department of Political Science & Department of
Law, University of Cambridge, Hughes Hall, UK; 4Law School, University of Southampton, UK; 'John Jay
college of Criminal Justice, City University of New York, New York, USA and 6School of Law, University of
Edinburgh, UK
Corresponding author: Jared Holley; Email: j.holley@ed.ac.uk


  Abstract
  This editorial considers how scholars interested in issues of global constitutionalism should
  approach  the questions that have concerned those interested in enlightenment. Reflecting
  on the relocation of the journal's editorial offices to Edinburgh, we foreground discussions
  from the historiography of the long eighteenth century that should be of interest to scholars
  of international relations, international law and political theory. Two main contributions
  are emphasized. First, a contextualist and political approach to enlightenment invites us to
  see global constitutionalism as a strategic response to crisis, aiming to combat fanaticism.
  Second, a global approach to enlightenment invites us to continue enlarging the world of
  global constitutionalism. Taken together, the contributions support the journal's ongoing
  efforts to decolonize global constitutionalism by enjoining readers and contributors to
  attend to neglected sides and sites of global constitutional processes.

Keywords: enlightenment; global constitutionalism; intellectual history; political thought


Race  and  Enlightenment:  the  Hume  controversy
The  relocation in January 2025 of the journal's editorial offices to Edinburgh provides a
welcome  opportunity  to reflect on the relationship between global constitutionalism and
enlightenment.  The city of Edinburgh is widely recognized as the epicentre ofthe Scottish
Enlightenment,  with statues of Adam  Smith  (1723-1790)  and David  Hume   (1711-1776)
fixtures of its famous Royal Mile. The University of Edinburgh, too, is remembered as the
site of debates among   faculty and students that helped  to distil and consolidate what
Hume came to call 'the science of man'. But Global Constitutionalism's arrival in
Edinburgh   comes  in the  wake  of controversy  that has decidedly  lowered  the public
standing  of both Hume   and  the distinctive blend of natural history, moral philosophy
and  medicine to which  he referred.
   In 2020, University  students successfully petitioned to have Hume's  name  removed
from  the tallest building on campus.  The controversy  invoked  debates that have  been


© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press. This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms
of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted
re-use, distribution and reproduction, provided the original article is properly cited.