About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



103 Detroit Mercy L. Rev. Online J. 1 (2026)

handle is hein.journals/dtmercyl103 and id is 1 raw text is: 












The Gales of November Remembered:1

The Edmund Fitzgerald, CulturalHeritage

Protection, and Underwater Tombs


RYAN  M. SEIDEMANN*

I.  INTRODUCMION

     Shipwrecks  capture the human  imagination.2  The popular  culture
that has evolved  from  such events as the tragic RMS   Titanic and SS
Edmund Fitzgerald sinkings3 and the alluring treasure finds of the
Nuestra  Senora   de Atocha   and  the SS  Brother Jonathan4   contain
elements  of mystery, harsh environments,  and riches. Especially in the
cold  of the Great Lakes, these sites have become  well-preserved time
capsules from  which  interpretations of humanity's  seafaring past can





    1. GORDON  LIGHTFOOT, The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald, on Summertime
Dream  (Vinyl Record, Reprise Recs. 1976).
* Ryan M. Seidemann earned a Bachelor of Arts in Anthropology from Florida State
University, a master's degree in Anthropology, a Bachelor of Civil Law, a Juris
Doctorate at Louisiana State University, and a Ph.D. in Urban Studies/Urban
Anthropology from the University of New Orleans. Dr. Seidemann is a licensed lawyer
in Louisiana and Vermont, and he previously served as an Assistant Attorney General
and Chief of the Lands & Natural Resources Section of the Louisiana Department of
Justice. Dr. Seidemann has authored or co-authored more than 100 publications on
human  remains, cemeteries, and environmental and mineral law. As the current
General Counsel for The Water Institute, Dr. Seidemann specializes in complex
interactions of the law and sciences, with a particular focus on disaster response,
mortuary archaeology, and historic preservation. Dr. Seidemann also holds active
adjunct professor appointments with Arizona State University's School of Human
Evolution & Social Change, the University of New Orleans' Departments of
Anthropology & Sociology and Planning & Urban Studies, and Southern University's
Law Center. All opinions expressed herein are solely those of the Author and do not
necessarily represent the opinions or positions of his employers.
    2. ROBERT  F. MARX, SHIPWRECKS OF THE WESTERN HEMISPHERE: 1492-1825 xi
 (David McKay Co., Inc., N.Y. 1975).
    3.  See, e.g., WALTER LORD, A NIGHT TO REMEMBER (Penguin Books, 4th ed. 2012)
 (documenting the Titanic sinking); TITANIC, VHS (Paramount Pictures 1997) (popular
 Hollywood adaptation of the Titanic sinking); LIGHTFOOT, supra note 1 (folk-rock
 ballad on the EdmundFitzgeralds sinking).
    4.  See generally Lawrence D. Bradley, Jr., U.S. Treasure Trove Law, 10-SPG
EXPERIENCE 24, 24-28 (2000) (discussing the attraction and discoveries of the Atocha
and the Brotherfonathan); see also Treasure Salvors, Inc. v. Unidentified Wrecked and
Abandoned  Sailing Vessel, 569 F.2d 330, 336-38 (5th Cir. 1978) (discussing the
Atocha).