About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



27 CUNY L. Rev. Footnote Forum 1 (2024)

handle is hein.journals/cunyform27 and id is 1 raw text is: 









    AN   EXEGESIS OF THE MEANING OF DOBBS:
    DESPOTISM, SERVITUDE, & FORCED BIRTH

                          Athena  D. Mutual



    I.  THE D OBBSD  ECISION ...........................................................4
    II. IAM  THE PEOPLE: HOW  DOBBSFURTHER UNDERMINES
        DEMOCRACY ......................................................................... 6
    III. YOULOSE:  FORCED  BIRTH AND  THE COURT'S  THEORY   OF
        LIFE ....................................................................................10
    IV. NOT  YOUR BODY, NOT YOUR  CHOICE: INVOLUNTARY
        SERVITUDE  & INEQUALITY..............................................  11
    V.  YOUR  BODYISMINE:  IS THIS A STATE INTEREST?......... 17
    VI. AND  YOU'RE HAVING  MY  BABY  ................................... 21
    VII.   CATHEDRAL MAN AS BENEFICIARY: SURVEILLANCE,
        PUNISHMENT,  &  OTHER  CONSEQUENCES ........................ 24



    The Dobbs   decision has been leaked. Gathered  outside of New
    York  City's St. Patrick's Old Cathedral, pro-choice protesters
    chant: Not the church, not the state, the people must decide their
    fate. i

    A white man wearing  a New York Fire Department  sweatshirt and
    standing on the front steps responds: I am the people, I am the
    people, I am the people, the people have decided, the court has



? Athena D. Mutua is a Professor of Law and Floyd H. & Hilda L. Hurst Faculty Scholar at
University at Buffalo, School of Law (SUNY). She specializes in the area of civil rights and
the critical analysis of the role of law in both facilitating and hindering justice across the in-
tersections of race, class, and gender. Professor Mutua is a founding member of the Critical
(Legal) Collective, an organization meant to safeguard and advance critical studies in the wake
of attacks on critical knowledge and multiracial democracy, and co-founder of ClassCrits, a
network of scholars exploring issues of law and political economy. Professor Mutua currently
serves as vice chair to the New York Advisory Committee to the United States Commission
on Civil Rights. She is married and has three adult sons. This essay was originally part of a
longer essay that Professor Mutua wrote titled: Reflections on Critical Race Theory in a Time
ofBacklash, 100 DEN. L. REV. 553 (2023). Parts of that original discussion on abortion are
incorporated here without citation.
    1 See KhaledaRahman,Man Tells Abortion Rights Activists 'Your Body Is Mine' in Viral
Video, NEWSWEEK (May 9, 2022, 5:29 AM), https://perma.cc/J9QW-7GTC.


I