About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



32 Critical Criminology 1 (2024)

handle is hein.journals/ctlcrm32 and id is 1 raw text is: 


Critical Criminology (2024) 32:1-3
https://doi.org/1 0.1007/si10612-024-09770-8




Editorial   (32)1


David  Brotherton1 - Jayne Mooney1

Published online: 21 May 2024
© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Nature B.V. 2024



This issue appears in the middle of deepening crises around the globe with state crimes
carried out on unimaginable scales while in the United States an authoritarian president-
in-waiting faces multiple criminal charges that would put any of us poor mortals in prison
for many lifetimes. Not for him alas, as once again bourgeois justice shows it true face in
its commitment  to serving the interests of the governing social order. Thus, crimes of the
powerful are business as usual here, a social fact that also goes for anywhere corporate
capitalist governance is hegemonic. Let us not forget that it was under the Obama regime
that the Department of Justice ensured that no banker went to prison after the heists of
big capital during the financial crisis of 2008. Hence, plus ga change would seem to be
the order of the day even  as nature continues to bellow that profit-based extractivism,
industrialism, private land ownership, consumerism   and  pollution bring us closer to
extinction every day.
   Despite these apocalyptic forebodings, hope is always  on the other side of despair,
as Sartre once dialectically remarked. In this vein, we might note the explosion of pro-
Palestinian protests especially with the student encampments  across the United States.
In the land  that boasts of its democratic credentials free speech has effectively been
criminalized. Is this evidence of a growing   legitimacy crisis among  elite-dominated,
increasingly unresponsive systems of power?  Such  a question is especially pertinent in
esteemed  institutions of higher learning where students pay more than $60,000 a year for
tuition and are left wondering what have these knowledge factories become? Whose space
is this? To what end have we been turned into consumers  of programs/credentials and/or
clients of the institution if my future is getting more and not less precarious?
   The camps  being  set up are not just valiant efforts to take a stand in defense of self-
determination but are expressions of youth's growing frustration with living in a nation
where  political life is controlled by a gerontocracy, the economy faithfully serves the
billionaire class, and women  face the distinct possibility of a federal ban on abortion
among  so many  other shortcomings  of a truly democratic society. This contrast between
the missions that universities are supposed to uphold and what they do was captured in a
recent New  York Times (4/28/24) report on the crisis of control facing administrations.
A  former Ivy league police chief was asked to comment  and  unwittingly pointed to the
cause of so much   student disenchantment: This  is the big concern, right? That these
encampments   will be there forever? ...it becomes a reason for people to not choose your


E   David Brotherton
    criticalcrmjournal@gmail.com

    John Jay College of Criminal Justice, New York, USA


Springer