About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



20 Austl. Tax F. 3 (2005)

handle is hein.journals/austraxrum20 and id is 1 raw text is: Are asset revaluation reserve
distributions 'ordinary income' for
discretionary beneficiaries?
Brett Freudenberg*
This article will analyse whether an asset revaluation reserve distribution made by a
trustee of a discretionary trust could be regarded as ordinary income for the receiving
beneficiary.This is important as normally only the capital gains tax treatment is
considered, with the resultant conclusion that such a distribution is not assessable.
Through this article's analysis, the accepted position that an asset revaluation
reserve distribution has no adverse income tax consequences for a beneficiary of a
discretionary trust will be challenged. In particular, it will be submitted that the receipt
of such a distribution by a discretionary beneficiary could be assessable as ordinary
income.
The article will initially consider whether an asset revaluation is ordinary income
for the trust estate itself Then the conduit theory's application to asset revaluation
reserve distributions by trustees of discretionary trusts will be considered. Following
this analysis, the article will consider whether the receipt of an asset revaluation
reserve distribution is ordinary income for the beneficiary of a discretionary trust.

3

*   Brett Freudenberg is a lecturer at Griffith Business School, Griffith Universit. The
author would like to thank Associate Professor Peter McDermott, Reader in Law,
University of Queensland, for his endless support and guidance.
This paper was accepted for publication on 31 August 2004.