About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



B-186749 1 (1976-10-19)

handle is hein.gao/gaobadefm0001 and id is 1 raw text is: 







                                            THE  COMPTROLLER OENERAL
Cd            CECISION             .0OF THE UNITED STATEB
                                            WASHINGTON, D,0,o20549



              FILE:    1d6749                      DATE;   October 19, 1976

              MATTER OF: Hunck Systems, Inc.


              DIGEST:

                        Where bidder submits bid bonds which expire prior to
                        120-day bid acceptance period agency's rejection of
                        bid as nonresponsive pursuant to mandatory language
                        of ASPR g 2-40492(h) is proper,  Rationale of 38
                        Comp. Gen, 532 is applicable to instanc case since
                        Government's interest would not be secured after
                        expiratio  of bid bonds chus making it possible for
  .                     bidder to decide after opening of bids whether to
                        have its bid rejected, to prejudice of other bidders
                        and contrary to competitive bidding principles.


                   By letter dated June 17, 1976, Munck Systems, Inc. (funck).
             protested  the proposed award of a contract for the furniahing
             and  installation of two 35-ton bridge cranes at Dover Air Force
             Base,  Delaware, and Travis .Air Force Base, California, to any
             other  bidder under invitation for bids (IFB) F07603-76-00016, issued
             by  the Air Force on April 5, 1976.  The IFB, which had a 120-day
             acceptance  period, provided for a single award or, in the alternative,
             separate  awards for each air base and for the furnishing of a bid
             bond  in the amount of 20 perrent of the bid prico.  At bid opening
             onH  ay 27, 1976, 10 bids were received, with Munck the apparent low
             bidder  on a sinble-award basis.

                   In response to the IFB's bid bond requirement, Kunck submitted
              two irrevocable letters of credit with its bid, both in the amount
              of $75,000.  Letter number 0304, dated May 26, 1976, for Travis
              Air Force Base, expired June 1, 1976.  Letter nuiber 0305, dated
              May 26, 1976, for Dover Air Force Base, expired June 30, 1976.
              By letter dated June 4, 1976, the iesuing bank amended the expitation
              date of letter of credit number 0304 to June 30, 1976.

                   By telephone conversations on June 15 and 17, 1976, Munck was
             advised  by the Air Force that its bid had been rejected as non-
             responsive  based on the fact that the letters of credit submitted
             by Munck  expired prior to the 120day acceptance period provided for
             in  the IFB. Subsequently,  on June 21, 1976, the isouing bank amended
             both  letters of credit, reducing their amounts to $33,000 and extend-
             ing  their expiration dates to September 27, 1976.


S