About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



1 [1] (August 27, 2020)

handle is hein.crs/govdbmk0001 and id is 1 raw text is: 








                                                                                             August  27,2020

Biometric Entry-Exit System: Legislative History and Status


The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is statutorily
required to develop and implement an automatedbiometric
(i.e., physical characteristics such as fingerprints, face, or
irises) entry-exit systemfor foreign nationals (referred to as
aliens in innigration law) traveling into andoutof the
United States. The goals of this systemare to strengthen
nationalsecurityandhelp enforce innigration law without
disrupting the flow of authorized travel and commerce. The
biometric entry systemis said to be fully operationalized,
whereas thebiometric exit systemis still being
implemented.

Legislative History
Since mandating the development of an automated entry-
exit systemin 1996, Congress has amendedthe system's
requirements and deadlines on several occasions, including
by adding a biometric componentin 2001. A timeline of
related laws includes the following:
September  1996: The Illegal Imnigration Reform and
Innigrant Responsibility Actof 1996 (IIRIRA; P.L. 104-
208), Section 110, required the Attorney General (AG) to
develop an automated entry-exit systemthatwould collect
records of alien arrivals and departures by September 1998.
October 1998: Two  appropriations acts (P.L. 105-259 and
P.L. 105-277) amended Section 110of IIRIRA to extend
the deadline for implementing the entry-exit systemto
October 1998 for airports and to March2001 for land and
seaports of entry (POEs).
June 2000: The Imnmigration and Naturalization Service
Data ManagementImprovement   Act of 2000 (P.L. 106-
215) amended IIRIRA Section 110to describe the entry-
exit systemin greater detail and imposednew deadlines of
December  2003 for implementation of the entry -exit system
at all U.S. airports and seaports, December 2004 for
implementation at the 50busiest land POEs as defined by
the AG, and December 2005 for making data fromthe
systemavailable to innigration officers at allPOEs.
October 2000: The VisaWaiverPermanentProgramAct
(P.L. 106-396), Section 205, required the AGto develop
and implement a fully automatedentry-exit systemto
collect arrival and departure records for travelers under the
Visa WaiverProgramat  sea and airPOEs by October 2001.
October 2001: The Uniting and Strengthening Americaby
Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and
Obstruct TerrorismAct (USA PATRIOT  Act; P.L. 107-56),
Section 414, required the AGto implement the IIRIRA
entry-exit systemwith all deliberate speed. Theact also
directed the AG, in the development of the system, to focus
on utilization of biometric technology and tamper-resistant
documents. The law also required that theentry-exit system
interface with certain law enforcement databases to identify
individuals who may pose a threatto nationalsecurity.


May  2002: The Enhanced Border Security and Visa
Reform Act of 2002 (P.L. 107-173), Section 302, required
the AG, in developing the integrated entry-exit systemat
POEs, to use the technology standard under the PATRIOT
Act, establish an arrival and departure database, and make
all alien admissibility security databases interoperable (i.e.,
able to share data with other databases).
December  2004: The Intelligence Reformand Terrorism
Prevention Act of 2004 (P.L. 108-458), Section 7208,
required DHS (which was created in late 2002 and as sumed
responsibility forthe nation's entry-exit system) to develop
a plan to accelerate the full implementation of an automated
biometric entry-exit system
August2007:  The Implementing Recommendations of the
9/11 Commission Act of 2007 (P.L. 110-53), Section 711,
required DHS to establish a biometric exit systemto record
the departure of all Visa Waiver Program air travelers by
August2008.
September  2008: The DHS Appropriations Act, 2009 (P.L.
110-329) withheld certain funding for the legacy United
States Visitor and Innigrant Status Indicator Technology
(US-VISIT) programuntil DHS planned, piloted, and
reported onabiometric air exit program
December  2015 :The Consolidated Appropriations Act,
2016 (P.L. 114-113) authorized fee increases on L-1 and H-
lB vis as to provide up to $1 billion dollars for DHS to
implement abiometric exit systembeginningin FY2017.

Executive Order-s
The executive branch has also recently been involved in
influencing thedevelopmentofa biometric entry-exit
system Actionby  the Trump Administration includes the
following:
March  2017: Executive Order 13780, Protecting the Nation
from Foreign Terrorist Entry into the United States, ordered
DHS  to expedite the completion andimplementation ofa
biometric entry-exit tracking system.

Biometric E ntry System
In December2006, DHS  fully implemented a biometric
entry systemfor foreign nationals. It is part of the primary
inspection at U.S. POEs. During primary inspection, U.S.
Customs  and Border Protection (CBP) officers conduct a
brief interview with travelers, examine travel documents,
and check travelers against the Interagency Border
Inspection System(IBIS), a database of alleged and
convicted criminals. Officers also conduct identity
verification by entering some ofthe travelers' biographical
(e.g., pas sport information) and biometric (e.g., finger scans
and digital photographs) identification into the US-VISIT
system U.S. citizens are not required to provide biometrics
upon entry to the United States.


h          o ' s ' . ' :


k


pgpg\\\ \\