About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



4 You Make the Call 1 (2002)

handle is hein.blasports/ansrvds0004 and id is 1 raw text is: 














Volume  4, Number 1


                                        {Spring 20021






NCAA BYLAW AND DECISION THAT FOREIGN STUDENT IS INELIGIBLE TO
PARTICIPATE IN NCAA ATHLETICS UPHELD

NCAA   v. LaSege, 53 S.W.3d 77 (S.C. Kentucky June 14, 2001)

Lasege, a  Nigerian citizen, enrolled at the University of Louisville during the 1999-2000
academic year to play basketball. In accordance with NCAA rules, before he could participate
the University declared him ineligible because he had previously entered into a professional
basketball contract and received benefits for playing basketball in Russia. The University asked
the NCAA   to reinstate Lasege due to his unfamiliarity with NCAA rules and other mitigating
factors. The NCAA's   Subcommittee  on  Student-Athlete Reinstatement denied this request,
mainly because Lasege had clearly signed a contract with an agent and professional team prior to
enrolling at Louisville.

Following the Subcommittee's ruling, Lasege sued the NCAA seeking an injunction requiring the
NCAA   to reverse its decision and reinstate him. The trial court found that there was sufficient
evidence to show that the NCAA  had acted in an arbitrary and capricious manner and entered a
temporary injunction ordering the NCAA to reinstate Lasege.

The trial court also addressed the University's concern that the NCAA could potentially impose
sanctions on it under NCAA bylaw  19.8 if the injunction was subsequently vacated. This bylaw
allows the NCAA  to seek restitution from member institutions who permit ineligible athletes to
participate pursuant to a court order that is eventually vacated. After finding that the bylaw was
invalid because it prevented parties from availing themselves of the protections of the court
system, the trial court enjoined the NCAA from future action under the bylaw.

The  NCAA   appealed  to the court of appeals, which found the trial court's findings to be
supported by substantial evidence and denied the NCAA's motion. The NCAA  then appealed to
the Supreme Court of Kentucky.


@ Copyright 2002, National Sports Law Institute of Marquette University Law School


Page 1