About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



1 1 (September 5, 2025)

handle is hein.amenin/aeiafgv0001 and id is 1 raw text is: 

















The F'scal mpact of Imm'grat', on:


An Update


Via PA. Orrenius, Alan  D. Viard, and  Madeline   Zavodny


September 2025


inmigrants have an overall posii ve ical inpact on the US-an effect driven by high-skilled
immigrarnts, Low-skilled imrnigrants, like their US-borr co:unterparts, impose a net fiscal cost
However, recent studies show that the ndect fiscal effcts of low-skilled imrnigration are positive,
partly ofsettinng the egative direct scalrnpact. Moreover, imrigrants will help bear the cost
of future policy changes required to ddress the grcwing national debt. Sma||er imrnigration
inflows might reduce fiscal pressure on state and local governrments but would ncrease fiscal
pressure on the federal gov'ernment and slnow econoric growth.


immigration rose quickly in the post-*pandemric years.,
The  US foreign-born population hit Si million, and
its snare of the total population reached 15.4 percent,
exceeding the previous high set in 191o (Figure 1i),
Record  immigration in recent years, in combination
with ongoing fiscal ch.allengcs, has prompted renewd
interest in immigration's nscal impact-its effect on
government revenues and expenditures.
   While the nation's fiscal situation has worsened con-
siderably over the past decade, with the debt ballooning
to 98 percent of anmnual gross domestic product (GDP)
from 73 percent a decade before, immigration is not the
reason (CBO  ,25c). In fact, the Congressional Budget
Office (CBO) projected that the surge in post-pandemic
immigration would  add  signinicantly to net federal


  The viewvs expressed here ate soley those of the authors and do not
Reserve System.


revenue over the next 10 years (itBO 2024). The best
studies on the topic support this view-namely, that
immigration as a whole does not add to the federal debt,
Rather, the fiscal cost of irnmigration-to the extent such
a cost occurs-is incurred at mainly the state and local
levels due to the provision of public education to the chil-
dren of imnigrants, most of whoAm are born in the US.
   The National Academies  of Sciences, Engineering,
and Medicine gold standard study on the fiseal impat
of inmigration concluded that irnigrants' average life-
time fiscal impact was positive (Blaur and Mackic 2017).
The net positive impact, however, was driven by very
large positive contributions from college-educated
imnmigrants, partly offset by sizable negative fiscal
impacts of  inigrants with a high school diploma or


reflect those of the Federal Reserve Bark of Da:las or the Federal


AMERICAN ENTERPRISE INSTITUTE