About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



1 1 (January 2018)

handle is hein.amenin/aeiabtp0001 and id is 1 raw text is: 

























y ohn F. Pfaff


januar .]8


-[his brief explains how Congress and the president can best help reduce  ur ouatris outsized
eliarnce on imiprisoirent, a goal with ire, ridesp-ead bparisan st:pport. Sr',ce[i fitretios
vil need to target issm.es that previous efots h.ave overlooked cer ignored, and they weil need
•  ke betr- acount cottc  . it -oru ways that Costs, benefits, and responsibit;ies are fractuted
acriss city, county, state, and ederai governtents If designed oroOeiy, :, - ed:ea
efi-t rcoudpa   mrtt ro1 H ; pasing oe rericattire syIe to adorpt Wri efei Weast,
as wi as aote hum-none, aopto.,ches ID manarg and reducing ,c~:r-.


Despite some of the most extreme ideological
dihides ia modem tines, bt) chlambers of  ngress
have .ecently . ade genuine bipartisan efforts to
ref01 on 1natio:s cdiAfla justice syste, esjjetally
its reliance on incarceration, The need for such reform
is dea The U ited States bas the lighest incarcc-
ation. rate in the world, detaifning neany 5 percent
of the wiATf's prisoners, and we surely lead the world
when it comes to the fration of people with any
sort of crinnai record or colniction. And a g owing
b'ody of research suggests that in carceraon does


not provide the pubi'c-safety returns that its pro-
potint[s -,i'b.,
  So far, most congressional effot''s have focused
on fi,,tug th- federal svte a While much is wrong
wjtl the federal system, it is ntinately a reJatvely
minor player in crininal jst'ote: State systems hold
acarly 90 percent of all prisoners and far greater
percentages of pretrial deta'nees, parolees, and pro-
bationers, it is thus eicotmitg to see that on recent
federal proposal. the Reverse Mass Incarceraon
Act (RMIA), takes direct aim at the higger state


Technically, the US has the second-highest incarceration rate, with the Seychelles in first, Bat the Seychelles has
feer than 700 people in prison or jail, compared to over a  i-illion in the US (World Prison Brief, icd)oShannon
et al, (z01) report that 2 perceT of the adult US population has been to prison, and 8 percent have a felony con'.c ion;
for Adrican Americans, those percentages are i5 percent and 33 percent.
The most carrent, comprehensive rex. ewa of the literature on the cnn.ime-reduci.g impact of incarcerton is Roodnian 2oi,
which suggests it has a nminina inpact, certainly during our curacnt period of high in.carcerantion rates and low cime rates.
For example, see the Smarter Sentencing Act; tlhe Corrections Oversight, Recidivism Reduction, and Eliminating
Costs for Taxpayers in Our National System Act; the Safe, Accountable, Fair, and Effct'JVC Jlstice Act; and the
Sentencing Reform and Corrections Act,


A Smarter Approach to Federal
Assistance with State-Level Criminal

justice R eform