About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



8 Eur. J. Health L. 293 (2001)
Medical Research Involving Human Subjects: Towards an International Legal Framework?

handle is hein.journals/eurjhlb8 and id is 303 raw text is: European Journal of Health Law 8: 293-298, 2001.                 293
© 2002 Kluwer Law International. Printed in the Netherlands.
EDITORIAL
Medical Research Involving Human Subjects: Towards an
International Legal Framework?
Introduction
There are several reasons to address the protection of research subjects not
only at the national, but also at the international level. Apart from the fact that
human rights are at stake, medical research is not confined to national
borders. The evergrowing international cooperation in this field together with
the increasing mobility of persons and capital require a common international
framework to establish a minimum level of protection and reduce the
divergence between national laws as much as possible. Basically, therefore,
international standards must be welcomed.
In the field of human subject research, however, the problem is not that
there is too little international standard setting, but rather that there seems to
be too much of it. The number of (draft) international standards concerning
human subject research is steadily increasing. As far as good clinical practice
in clinical trials on pharmaceuticals for human use are concerned, we have
already the ICH-GCP guideline.' Looking at international standards relating
to all human subject research, there is first of all the Declaration of Helsinki
which was recently revised by the World Medical Association (WMA)2.
Furthermore, also the Council for International Organisations of Medical
Sciences (CIOMS) is now updating its 1993 International ethical guidelines3.
At the European level apart from the recent European Community Directive
on good clinical practice in clinical trials on medicinal products  the Council
of Europe Steering Committee on Bioethics (CDBI) has recently declassified
(for consultation purposes) a draft additional Protocol to the Convention on
Human Rights and Biomedicine on biomedical research. There are
considerable differences in the status, scope and contents between these
documents. This may create confusion, in particular where they do not
support and complement each other. In fact, there is reason to doubt whether
all of them can and will contribute to the development of a comprehensive
international framework.