About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



15 Lewis & Clark L. Rev. 633 (2011)
Samantar and the Future of Foreign Official Immunity

handle is hein.journals/lewclr15 and id is 649 raw text is: SAMANTAR AND THE FUTURE OF FOREIGN
OFFICIAL IMMUNITY
by
David P. Stewar
The U.S. Supreme Court's recent decision in Samantar v. Yousuf
resolved a long-standing issue of U.S. law by determining that the
Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act does not apply to claims brought
against individual foreign government officials, as opposed to the foreign
government itself The Court also said, however, that individual officials
might instead be entitled to immunity under common law principles of
foreign sovereign immunity. In remanding the case for a determination
of that question, the Court effectively required the executive branch to
clarify the circumstances in which such immunity might apply to visiting
officials of foreign government for actions taken by them on behalf of
their governments.
This Article examines the background and reasoning of the Samantar
decision as well as the subsequent determination of the U.S. government
to deny immunity in the circumstances of that case. It contrasts that
determination with a submission by the executive branch in a separate
case recommending that limited testimonial immunity for a former
President of Columbia. In this developing area of the law, these two
submissions presumably reflect the executive branch's considered view of
how relevant legal principles of customary international law should be
applied in future cases as well. The Article raises a number of questions
about the practical as well as theoretical implications of the government's
position.
I.     INTRODUCTION             .......................................... 634
II.    THE DOCTRINE OF SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY......                      ...... 636
III.   THE SAMANTAR DECISION              ....................  .... ...... 644
IV.    SUBSEQUENT DEVELOPMENTS                     ...........   ............ 648
V.     DOCTRINAL IMPLICATIONS              ..................   .............. 651
VI.    THE URIBE SUBPOENA.              .........................  ..... 659
VII.   CONCLUSION              ......................................... 662
Visiting Professor (International and  Transnational Law), Georgetown
University Law Center, stewartd@law.georgetown.edu. Professorial Lecturer, Johns
Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies. Member, Inter-
American juridical Committee. The author previously served as Assistant Legal
Adviser, U.S. Department of State.

633