About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



5 Yale J. on Reg. 367 (1988)
Sources of the Crisis in Liability Insurance: An Economic Analysis

handle is hein.journals/yjor5 and id is 373 raw text is: Perspectives on the Insurance Crisis
Sources of the Crisis in Liability
Insurance: An Economic Analysis
Richard N. Clarket
Frederick Warren-Boultontt
David D. Smithttt
Marilyn J. Simontttt
The existence, nature, and causes of a crisis in the market for
property-casualty insurance in the United States remain the subject of ex-
tensive debate. Two alarming features of current markets, unaffordability
and unavailability, are cited as evidence that something is amiss.' Premi-
ums charged for several lines of property-casualty insurance coverage have
soared over the past several years. Stories detailing two to three hundred
percent rate increases for daycare centers, five thousand percent increases
for asbestos removal firms, and fifty to one hundred percent increases for
medical malpractice coverage for obstetricians have become commonplace.'
t Member of Technical Staff, AT&T Bell Laboratories. A.B. 1975, University of Michigan; A.M.
1977, Ph.D. 1980, Harvard University.
#t Deputy Assistant Attorney General for Economic Analysis, Antitrust Division, United States
Department of Justice. B.A. 1967, Yale University; M.P.A. 1969, M.A. 1969, Ph.D. 1975, Princeton
University.
ff Senior Economist, Economists Incorporated. B.A. 1975, Kalamazoo College; M.A. 1977,
Ph.D. 1979, University of Michigan.
    Economist, Antitrust Division, United States Department of Justice. A.B. 1973, Barnard
College; M.A. 1975, Ph.D. 1978, Princeton University.
The opinions expressed in this paper are not necessarily those of AT&T Bell Laboratories, the
United States Department of Justice, or Economists Incorporated. The authors wish to thank Debra
Ballen, Rodger Lawson, Frank Mathewson, Neil Roberts, Albert Smiley, Michael Trebilcock, Greg
Werden, Robert Willmore, Ralph A. Winter, and the editorial staff of the YALE JOURNAL ON REGU-
LATION for their valuable advice. Earlier versions of this paper were presented at the session on
Insurance Availability and Pricing, Allied Social Sciences Association Meetings (Dec. 29, 1986); the
session on Solutions to the Insurance Crisis: Exploring the Link Between Tort Reform and Insurance
Regulation, Yale Law School (Feb. 27, 1987); and included as an appendix to U.S. DEP'T OF JUS-
TICE, TORT POLICY WORKING GROUP, AN UPDATE ON THE LIABILITY CRISIS (1987).
1. See U.S. DEP'T OF JUSTICE, TORT POLICY WORKING GROUP, REPORT OF THE TORT POL-
ICY WORKING GROUP ON THE CAUSES, EXTENT AND POLICY IMPLICATIONS OF THE CURRENT
CRISIS IN INSURANCE AVAILABILITY AND AFFORDABILITY 6-13 (1986) [hereinafter TORT POLICY
REPORT].
2. See, e.g., id. at 6-16; U.S. DEP'T OF JUSTICE, TORT POLICY WORKING GROUP, AN UPDATE
Copyright C 1988 by the Yale Journal on Regulation.                           367