About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



75 J. Crim. L. & Criminology 234 (1984)
Equity and Discretionary Justice: The Influence of Race on Police Arrest Decisions

handle is hein.journals/jclc75 and id is 248 raw text is: 00914169/84/7501-234
THE JOURNAL OF CRIMINAL LAW & CRIMINOLOGY                      Vol. 75, No. I
Copyright 0 1984 by Northwestern University School of Law    Printed in USA
EQUITY AND DISCRETIONARY JUSTICE:
THE INFLUENCE OF RACE ON
POLICE ARREST DECISIONS*
DOUGLAS A. SMITH**
CHRISTY A. VISHER***
LAURA A. DAVIDSON****
I. INTRODUCTION
This paper examines the degree to which race influences police ar-
rest decisions. Two types of possible racial bias are examined. The first,
most often addressed in previous research, is suspect-directed and exam-
ines whether blacks are more likely to be arrested than whites. The sec-
ond type of police bias is victim-directed and examines whether police
are equally responsive to black and white victims of crime. We found
little evidence of suspect-directed racial bias. Our analysis does indi-
cate, however, that police are more responsive to white victims of crime.
The implications of these findings for the equitable administration of
justice are then considered.
II. THE POTENTIAL FOR BIAS IN POLICE ARREST DECISIONS
Since the discovery of police discretion, scholars have debated the
equity of police decisionmaking. The discretionary nature of policing,
coupled with the powerful implications of police discretion in the justice
system, defines the primary issue of concern: whether decisions to arrest
are influenced by suspect characteristics such as race, sex, and age. In
light of the potentially severe social, economic, and legal consequences
faced by arrestees, it is of singular concern that such decisions be in-
* We would like to express our appreciation to Professor Roger Parks of the School for
Public and Environmental Affairs at Indiana University for making the Police Services Study
data available to us and for providing support and encouragement for this research.
** Assistant Professor, Institute of Criminology, University of Maryland. Ph.D., (Sociol-
ogy) Indiana University, 1982; M.A., Indiana University, 1980; B.A., Florida Atlantic Uni-
versity, 1978.
*** Research Fellow, National Research Council, Washington, D.C. Ph.D. (Sociology) In-
diana University, 1982; M.A., Indiana University; B.A., Trinity University, 1978.
**** Ph.D. student, Institute of Criminology, University of Maryland. M.A. (Criminology)
Florida State University, 1977; B.A., Florida State University, 1975.