About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline



78 Fordham L. Rev. 349 (2009-2010)
Protections for Electronic Communications: The Stored Communications Act and the Fourth Amendment

handle is hein.journals/flr78 and id is 351 raw text is: PROTECTIONS FOR ELECTRONIC
COMMUNICATIONS: THE STORED
COMMUNICATIONS ACT AND THE
FOURTH AMENDMENT
Alexander Scolnik *
As e-mail and other forms of electronic communications began becoming
widely used, Congress recognized the need to protect these new forms of
communication from impermissible intrusion. Unsure whether the flexible
approach to determining the extent of Fourth Amendment protections as
announced   in  Katz  v. United   States would   extend   to  electronic
communications, Congress enacted the Electronic Communications Privacy
Act (ECPA) to ensure a baseline level of protection. This Note argues that
the Fourth Amendment does extend to electronic communications and,
therefore, the provisions of the ECPA that allow the government to access
certain  electronic  communications  without a    search  warrant are
unconstitutional.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRO DUCTION  .......................................................................................... 350
I. COMMUNICATIONS AND THE FOURTH AMENDMENT ............................ 351
A .  The  Third-Party  D octrine ......................................................... 355
1. Delivery and Routing Information Directly Conveyed to
T hird  Parties  ...................................................................... 356
2. Records and Information Stored in Databases Managed
by  T hird  Parties ................................................................. 357
B. Fourth Amendment Standards Evolve with Technology ....... 361
1.  Telephone  Conversations ................................................... 362
a.  O lm stead  v. United  States ............................................ 362
b.  K atz  v. U nited  States .................................................... 363
2.  Postal  M ail ......................................................................... 365
3.  Telegraph  M essages ........................................................... 368
C. Legislative Actions To Protect Electronic Communications .... 372
1. Motivation for the Electronic Communications Privacy
A ct .....................................................................................  3 7 2
* J.D. Candidate, 2010, Fordham University School of Law; B.E., 2006, Cooper Union. I
would like to thank my advisor, Professor Katherine Strandburg, for her insightful comments
and feedback and my family and friends for their support and encouragement.